Scorecard · Scoreboard of Sat Oct 17, 2026

KAY

From
KAY
Subject
Your Sign to Save 25-40% OFF* + EXTRA 10%* on Select Styles✨
Preheader
+ Cardholders can enjoy EXTRA 5% OFF‡ qualifying purchases!
Sent
Oct 16, 2026, 5:18 pm MT
Type · Industry
Campaign · E-commerce
Themes
None tagged
Screenshot of the KAY email: Your Sign to Save 25-40% OFF* + EXTRA 10%* on Select Styles✨
As received, at phone width. About screenshots

Verdict · Rubric v1.0

Solid

24/40

Weakest dimension: Design & hierarchy (2/5).

Dimensions

  • Subject & preheaderjudgment

    Subject is specific and honest; the preheader adds a little but partly repeats it: "+ Cardholders can enjoy EXTRA 5% OFF‡ qualifying purchases!"

  • Clarityjudgment

    The main message is clear in the first screen, but the offer terms take some reading to pin down: "Your Sign to Save 25-40% OFF* + EXTRA 10%* on Select Styles✨"

  • Design & hierarchyboth

    Hard to scan on a phone: no clear focal point, small text, or image-only key copy: "Shop Now" (within the 3/5 cap set by: The main button is below the first phone screen)

  • Copy & voicejudgment

    Competent but generic: it could come from any brand in the category: "Indulge in the Keepers"

  • Call to actionjudgment

    A call to action exists but is generic or competes with several equal ones: "Shop Now"

  • Relevancejudgment

    A poor fit for the subscriber's stage or timing: no supporting line found

  • Trustjudgment

    Trustworthy overall, with minor pushy or unclear elements: no supporting line found

  • Technical hygienecheck

    capped at 2/5 by: The HTML is over 102KB, so Gmail clips it

Automated checks

  • NOT VERIFIEDMain button linkMain button “Shop Now”: could not connect (connection refused) on both tries.
  • PASSOther links24 other links checked; could not be checked at: link.kay.com.
  • PASSLink domainsAll links go to the sender's own domains or its email platform.
  • NOT VERIFIEDUnsubscribe linkUnsubscribe link found (a link marked unsubscribe): could not connect (connection refused) on both tries.
  • PASSSubject prefixThe subject does not start with RE: or FW:.
  • PASSDMARC alignmentDMARC passed for em.kay.com (domain policy: reject).
  • PASSDMARC recordThe sending domain publishes a DMARC record.
  • PASSPostal addressPostal address found in the email text: 375 Ghent Rd., Akron, Ohio 44333
  • PASSOne-click unsubscribeOne-click unsubscribe is supported (RFC 8058).
  • FAILHTML sizeThe HTML is 112KB, over Gmail's 102KB limit, so Gmail clips the email.
  • FAILPlain-text versionNo plain-text version: the email is HTML only.
  • PASSImage alt text1 of 18 content images lack alt text. Not counted: tracking pixels.
  • PASSIcon link labelsNo icon-only links.
  • PASSLive text (design)About 686 words of live text.
  • PASSLive text (hygiene)About 686 words of live text.
  • PASSPhone widthThe email fits a 375px phone screen.
  • FAILMain button positionMain button “Shop Now” starts 1016px down, below the first phone screen (667px).
  • PASSSingle main button0 buttons; no group of identical-looking buttons.
  • PASSBody text sizeBody text is 16px on a phone (median; smallest 10.5px; 5% under 14px; footer not counted).
  • PASSPreheaderPreheader: “+ Cardholders can enjoy EXTRA 5% OFF‡ qualifying purchases!”.
  • PASSMerge fieldsNo unfilled merge fields.
  • PASSTyposNot confirmed as a typo: “combinable” (suggested “commonable”), “dba” (suggested “ba”), “inbox” (suggested “into”), “storewide” (suggested “statewide”).
  • PASSTracking parametersNo problems found in tracking parameters.

Disagree with a score? Read how scores are made or email support@inboxteardown.com to request a rescore.