Daily Scoreboard · Sat Nov 21, 2026 · 1:15 am MT

Yesterday's sends, scored

Emails shown
74
Average
26.0/40
Hard fails
0

Best send yesterday

JARED Jewelers

30out of 40, Solid

"Black Friday is On! 20-30% Off* Select Styles"

E-commerce · campaign

Design & hierarchy 3/5: Hierarchy is present but weak: several elements compete, or key copy relies on images: "SHOP THE SALE"

Lowest score yesterday

Gap

21out of 40, Weak

"Introducing the GapStudio Winter Capsule"

Fashion · campaign

Design & hierarchy 1/5: Broken or unreadable on a phone: no hierarchy, layout failures, or key content lost without images: no supporting line found (within the 2/5 cap set by: Fewer than 50 words of live text)

All emails, ranked

  1. 1JARED Jewelers · E-commerceE-commerceBlack Friday is On! 20-30% Off* Select StylesFailed check: Plain-text versionCampaign30out of 40, Solid
  2. 2True Classic · FashionFashionBlack Friday: $449 Off, Laundry Can WaitFailed check: Body text size, PreheaderCampaign30out of 40, Solid
  3. 3e.l.f. Cosmetics · FashionFashion$5 off Bundles & Sets 🛍️ THIS WEEKEND ONLY!Campaign29out of 40, Solid
  4. 4Everlane · FashionFashionThe Styles You Reach for Most Are 40% OffFailed check: Main button position, Body text sizeCampaign29out of 40, Solid
  5. 5Everlane · FashionFashionBetter Gifts Under $50Failed check: Main button position, Body text sizeCampaign29out of 40, Solid
  6. 6Everlane · FashionFashionBuild Your Everyday Rotation for 40% LessFailed check: Main button position, Body text sizeCampaign29out of 40, Solid
  7. 7Kohl’s · E-commerceE-commerceTake an extra 20% off 🙌Failed check: Body text sizeCampaign29out of 40, Solid
  8. 8Patagonia · E-commerceE-commerceOur best-selling Black Hole bagsFailed check: Main button positionCampaign29out of 40, Solid
  9. 9Target · E-commerceE-commerceHey Reader! Use the Weekly Ad to get weekend-ready with Top Offers.Failed check: Main button position, Body text sizeCampaign29out of 40, Solid
  10. 10Bath & Body Works · FashionFashion40% off EVERYTHING* ends TODAY. get what you want while you can. 🤑Failed check: Icon link labels, Phone width, Main button positionCampaign28out of 40, Solid
  11. 11Bath & Body Works · FashionFashion⏰⏰⏰ FINAL HOURS - EVERYTHING* is still 40% off.Failed check: Icon link labels, Phone width, Main button positionCampaign28out of 40, Solid
  12. 12Bath & Body Works · FashionFashion🚨 LAST CHANCE 🚨 for 40% off the ENTIRE store.*Failed check: Icon link labels, Phone width, Main button positionCampaign28out of 40, Solid
  13. 13Blue Nile · E-commerceE-commerceUp to 40% Off* JewelryFailed check: Phone width, Main button position, Body text sizeCampaign28out of 40, Solid
  14. 14Brooklinen · HomeHome25% OFF THE VERY BEST IN BEDFailed check: Plain-text version, Icon link labels, Main button position, Body text sizeCampaign28out of 40, Solid
  15. 15Brooklinen · HomeHome25% OFF THE VERY BEST IN BEDFailed check: Plain-text version, Icon link labels, Main button position, Body text sizeCampaign28out of 40, Solid
  16. 16CB2 SALE · HomeHomeFLOOR SAMPLE SALEFailed check: Main button position, Body text sizeCampaign28out of 40, Solid
  17. 17Kiehl's Since 1851 · FashionFashionFirst Look: 30% OFF NEW Skincare!Failed check: Body text sizeCampaign28out of 40, Solid
  18. 18Nike · FashionFashionLucky Bryant’s go-to Jordan giftsFailed check: HTML size, Plain-text version, Phone width, Main button positionCampaign28out of 40, Solid
  19. 19Walmart · E-commerceE-commerceUp to 65% off is HERE 🔥Failed check: Main button position, Single main buttonCampaign28out of 40, Solid
  20. 20Walmart Black Friday · E-commerceE-commerceMore Black Friday Deals are live Nov. 23 🛒Failed check: Body text sizeCampaign28out of 40, Solid
  21. 21Bed Bath & Beyond · HomeHomeBeyond Black Friday = BIG Savings 🔥Failed check: Phone width, Body text sizeCampaign27out of 40, Solid
  22. 22Bed Bath & Beyond · HomeHomeSweet dreams start with a new mattress 💤Failed check: Phone width, Body text sizeCampaign27out of 40, Solid
  23. 23Blue Nile · E-commerceE-commerceDiamond Savings: 25% Off**Failed check: Phone width, Main button position, Body text sizeCampaign27out of 40, Solid
  24. 24J.Crew · FashionFashionThree new pieces you needFailed check: Body text sizeCampaign27out of 40, Solid
  25. 25KAY · E-commerceE-commerceBlack Friday Event Starts NOW 🖤 Up to 40% OFF* Select Styles & MOREFailed check: HTML size, Plain-text version, Main button positionCampaign27out of 40, Solid
  26. 26Lands' End · FashionFashionStock up on your favorites: 50% offFailed check: Plain-text version, Body text sizeCampaign27out of 40, Solid
  27. 27Quince · FashionFashionStarts now: Black Friday Early Access SaleFailed check: HTML size, Icon link labelsCampaign27out of 40, Solid
  28. 28Quince · E-commerceE-commerceYour Early Access deals are going, going…Failed check: Icon link labelsCampaign27out of 40, Solid
  29. 29realtor.com · HomeHome5 for Friday: Secluded Off-Grid Cabins for the Perfect Holiday-Chaos Escape—on Every BudgetFailed check: Plain-text version, Phone widthCampaign27out of 40, Solid
  30. 30Rothy's · FashionFashionCruisers at $99. (Hello, holidays!)Failed check: Live text (design), Live text (hygiene)Campaign27out of 40, Solid
  31. 31Royal Caribbean · TravelTravelSave up $950 off with Black Friday Preview Sale!Failed check: Body text sizeCampaign27out of 40, Solid
  32. 32Brooklinen · HomeHome40% Off Bundles AND a FREE GIFT? YES.Failed check: Plain-text version, Icon link labels, Main button position, Body text sizeCampaign26out of 40, Solid
  33. 33Brooklinen · HomeHome40% Off Bundles AND a FREE GIFT? YES.Failed check: Plain-text version, Icon link labels, Main button position, Body text sizeCampaign26out of 40, Solid
  34. 34DICK'S Sporting Goods · E-commerceE-commerce👀 Up to 80% OFF? You read that right! Score *unreal* savings on select styles nowFailed check: Icon link labels, Main button position, Single main button, Body text size, PreheaderCampaign26out of 40, Solid
  35. 35Gap · FashionFashionNew styles added >> get 60% off giftsFailed check: Live text (design), Live text (hygiene)Campaign26out of 40, Solid
  36. 36L.L.Bean · E-commerceE-commerceEven Better Than Flannel? New Flannel.Failed check: HTML size, Plain-text version, Phone width, Main button positionCampaign26out of 40, Solid
  37. 37Lands' End · FashionFashionDeck the halls for 50% off!Failed check: Plain-text version, Body text sizeCampaign26out of 40, Solid
  38. 38Macy's Black Friday · E-commerceE-commerce🚨NEW Black Friday deals just droppedFailed check: HTML sizeCampaign26out of 40, Solid
  39. 39Parachute · HomeHomeYou spend a third of your life in bed.Failed check: Postal address, Body text sizeCampaign26out of 40, Solid
  40. 40Quince · FashionFashionCashmere is on sale todayFailed check: HTML size, Icon link labelsCampaign26out of 40, Solid
  41. 41Target · E-commerceE-commerceThe deal of the day is too good to miss!Failed check: Main button position, Body text sizeCampaign26out of 40, Solid
  42. 42Target · E-commerceE-commerce40% off pajamas for all 🎉Failed check: HTML size, Main button position, Body text sizeCampaign26out of 40, Solid
  43. 43Williams Sonoma · HomeHomeUp to 60% off Early Black Friday Deals | KitchenAid® | Breville | Le Creuset & moreFailed check: Body text sizeCampaign26out of 40, Solid
  44. 44Williams Sonoma · HomeHomeEarly Black Friday Deals: Up to 60% off + clearance!Failed check: Body text sizeCampaign26out of 40, Solid
  45. 45Williams Sonoma · HomeHomeEarly Black Friday deals are HERE!Failed check: Body text sizeCampaign26out of 40, Solid
  46. 46ZALES · E-commerceE-commerceUp to 40% OFF* Select Styles 🖤 Black Friday Week Sale!Failed check: Plain-text version, Body text sizeCampaign26out of 40, Solid
  47. 47Aerie's Black Friday Sale · FashionFashionReal Rewards members get first dibs on Black Friday deals 💚❤️Failed check: HTML size, Phone width, Body text sizeCampaign25out of 40, Solid
  48. 48KAY · E-commerceE-commerceThese Black Friday Deals Are Your Sign to Shop 🖤Failed check: HTML size, Plain-text version, Main button positionCampaign25out of 40, Solid
  49. 49Our Place · HomeHomeThe Beauty of TitaniumFailed check: Main button position, Body text sizeCampaign25out of 40, Solid
  50. 50Quince · E-commerceE-commerceLast chance: Early Access SaleFailed check: HTML size, Icon link labelsCampaign25out of 40, Solid
  51. 51QVC · E-commerceE-commerceFree Shipping & 5 Easy Pays on EverythingFailed check: HTML size, Plain-text version, Main button position, Single main button, Body text sizeCampaign25out of 40, Solid
  52. 52realtor.com · HomeHomeBoomers Disproportionately Own Homes in Top School Districts—but Aren’t Blocking Young Families, Study Claims and More NewsFailed check: Plain-text version, Phone widthCampaign25out of 40, Solid
  53. 53Rothy's · FashionFashionON SALE: Best-selling Penny Clogs.Failed check: Live text (design), Live text (hygiene)Campaign25out of 40, Solid
  54. 54True Classic · FashionFashionMassive Markdowns On Limited-Time Black Friday DealsFailed check: Body text sizeCampaign25out of 40, Solid
  55. 55ZALES · E-commerceE-commerce⚡ Flash Sale: $50 OFF* $250Failed check: Plain-text version, Body text sizeCampaign25out of 40, Solid
  56. 56Banana Republic · FashionFashionA cardigan is always a good ideaFailed check: Live text (design), Live text (hygiene)Campaign24out of 40, Solid
  57. 57Best Buy Black Friday · E-commerceE-commerceBlack Friday has arrived at Best Buy - save now and get ready to gift 🎁Failed check: HTML size, Single main button, Body text sizeCampaign24out of 40, Solid
  58. 58Crate & Barrel SALE · HomeHomeIt’s Black Friday! Shop up to 50% off our biggest sale of the year →Failed check: HTML size, Phone width, Main button positionCampaign24out of 40, Solid
  59. 59DICK'S Early Black Friday Sale · E-commerceE-commerceStarting NOW: Up to 50% off deals during our Early Black Friday SaleFailed check: HTML size, Icon link labels, Main button position, Single main button, Body text size, PreheaderCampaign24out of 40, Solid
  60. 60Our Place · HomeHomeA New November RecipeFailed check: Live text (design), Live text (hygiene)Campaign24out of 40, Solid
  61. 61The North Face · FashionFashionMember Holiday Event exclusive savings are hereFailed check: Live text (design), Live text (hygiene), Phone widthCampaign24out of 40, Solid
  62. 62True Classic · FashionFashionWhy don't you try us on?Failed check: Live text (design), Live text (hygiene)Campaign24out of 40, Solid
  63. 63American Eagle · FashionFashionEarly access to Black Friday: EXTRA 40% OFF!!!🔑Failed check: HTML size, Body text sizeCampaign23out of 40, Weak
  64. 64Banana Republic · FashionFashionFestive, fun, a little unexpectedFailed check: Live text (design), Live text (hygiene)Campaign23out of 40, Weak
  65. 65Crate & Barrel Kids SALE · HomeHomeIT’S ON! Up to 50% off Black Friday deals + free shipping →Failed check: HTML size, Image alt text, Phone width, Main button positionCampaign23out of 40, Weak
  66. 66Crate & Barrel SALE · HomeHomeSave up to 50% on sofas, dining furniture & more for Black FridayFailed check: HTML size, Image alt text, Phone width, Main button positionCampaign23out of 40, Weak
  67. 67DICK'S Early Black Friday Sale · E-commerceE-commerce⏰ Up to 50% off Early Black Friday DEALS expire tomorrow ⏰ Shop now!Failed check: HTML size, Icon link labels, Main button position, Single main button, Body text size, PreheaderCampaign23out of 40, Weak
  68. 68Lemme · HealthHealthGift wellness essentials, up to 51% off 🎁Failed check: Live text (design), Live text (hygiene)Campaign23out of 40, Weak
  69. 69Parachute · HomeHomeThe Perfect Gift, Now 20% OffFailed check: Postal address, Body text sizeCampaign23out of 40, Weak
  70. 70QVC · E-commerceE-commercePowerful Laptop TSV® & Free Shipping + Get $20 OffFailed check: HTML size, Plain-text version, Main button position, Single main button, Body text sizeCampaign23out of 40, Weak
  71. 71CB2 · HomeHomeMoody lighting roundupFailed check: HTML size, Main button position, Body text sizeCampaign22out of 40, Weak
  72. 72Lola Blankets · HomeHomeMUST-HAVE HOLIDAY ACCESSORIESCampaign22out of 40, Weak
  73. 73Our Place · HomeHomeThe Biggest DealFailed check: Live text (design), Live text (hygiene)Campaign22out of 40, Weak
  74. 74Gap · FashionFashionIntroducing the GapStudio Winter CapsuleFailed check: Live text (design), Live text (hygiene)Campaign21out of 40, Weak
  • Strong 33-40
  • Solid 24-32
  • Weak under 24
  • Capped (a 1 on Trust or Technical hygiene)